To refine search, see subtopic The Stone Builders. Laterally related topics: Religion, Time and Space, Mathematics in Recreation, Art, Language and Literature, Music, Measurement, Arithmetic, Mathematics and Mysticism, Geometry, Discrete Mathematics, Optimization, Philosophy, Calculus, Statistics, Social Science, Logic, Computation, Probability, Applied Mathematics (General), Education, Algebra, Number Theory, Optics, Medicine, Creativity, Business, Fractals, and Science.
The Mathematics and the Liberal Arts pages are intended to be a resource for student research projects and for teachers interested in using the history of mathematics in their courses. Many pages focus on ethnomathematics and in the connections between mathematics and other disciplines. The notes in these pages are intended as much to evoke ideas as to indicate what the books and articles are about. They are not intended as reviews. However, some items have been reviewed in Mathematical Reviews, published by The American Mathematical Society. When the mathematical review (MR) number and reviewer are known to the author of these pages, they are given as part of the bibliographic citation. Subscribing institutions can access the more recent MR reviews online through MathSciNet.
Angell, Ian O. Megalithic mathematics, ancient almanacs or neolithic nonsense. Bull. Inst. Math. Appl. 14 (1978), no. 10, 253--258. (Reviewer: C. R. Fletcher.) SC: 01A10, MR: 80f:01002.
Discusses different explanations for the shapes of megalithic stone rings. The author briefly discusses some of the theories of Alexander Thom, which involve an astronomical calendar and an effort to make the circumference equal to 3 times the "diameter" rather than the irrational pi. He then discusses two new theories of his own. One explains the shapes of the stone rings as extensions of the ellipse, generated with three or four pegs and a string rather than with just the usual two. The other explains the shapes as an effort to store shadow lengths. Neither theory may be given entirely in earnest. A theme of the paper is how theories may start as intellectual games, go out of control, and be changed into pseudo-science. Closely related topics: The Stone Builders, Astronomy, The Calendar, The Ellipse, Pseudoscience, and Alexander Thom.
Atkinson, R. J. C. Obituary: Alexander Thom. J. Hist. Astronom. 17 (1986), no. 1, 73--75. SC: 01A70 (01A10), MR: 87h:01062.
As the author explains, some of the work of Alexander Thom remains controversial. However, Thom is to be credited with the invention of the subject of archaeoastronomy and with a number of interesting observations and theories. One of his interesting observations is the repeated occurrence of certain types of non-circular arrangements of stones. An interesting theory is his notion of a megalithic yard and rod, supposedly fairly consistent in Britain and Brittany. His theories of apparent alignments with solar and lunar events have been among the most influential, though are not always necessarily correct in all detail. Closely related topics: Alexander Thom, The Stone Builders, The Measurement of Distance, The Circle, and Astronomy.
Bérczi, Sz. Symmetry and technology in ornamental art of old Hungarians and Avar-Onogurians from the archaeological finds of the Carpathian Basin, seventh to tenth century A.D. Symmetry 2: unifying human understanding, Part 2. Comput. Math. Appl. 17 (1989), no. 4-6, 715--730. (Reviewer: Marjorie Senechal.) SC: 01A99 (01A10 92K99), MR: 91a:01058b.
Analysis of symmetries can be very helpful in better understanding archaeological art and artifacts. The types of symmetries not only show what the author describes as "intuitive mathematical development in ornamental art" but can also help trace relationships between different communities. Such studies are now relatively new, but with time should become "an accepted, standard part of the description of archaeological finds". In this article, the author discusses how all 7 types of strip/frieze patterns occur in Old Hungarian ornamental art, and develops a notion of a double frieze pattern, which is intermediary between frieze patterns and plane patterns. A number of these patterns occur (sometimes individualized) in Avar-Onogurian artifacts. The author's classification of double frieze patterns focuses on how the patterns are generated horizontally and vertically, and may be more useful for archaeological purposes than classification by the related plane patterns. The author gives examples of some plane patterns that came up somewhat naturally, including patterns from weaving, chained ring structures, and the optimal fitting of furs (a pmg plane pattern). The author compares the frequencies of certain symmetry patterns in collections from several cultures. Closely related topics: Hungary in the Middle Ages, Frieze Patterns, Plane Patterns, Double Frieze Patterns, and Metal Work.
Bogoshi, Jonas; Naidoo, Kevin and Webb, John. The oldest mathematical artefact. Math. Gaz. 71 (1987), no. 458, 294. (Reviewer: M. P. Closs.) SC: 01A10, MR: 89a:01003.
As the authors note, the oldest mathematical artifact known may be a piece of baboon fibula with 29 notches, dating from around 35,000 BC, and discovered in the mountains between South Africa and Swaziland. By comparison, the Ishango bone dates from about 9000 BC, and the Czechoslovakian wolf's bone with 57 notches dates from about 30,000 BC. Bushmen clans in Nambia apparently use similar bones for calendar sticks today. Includes photo. Closely related topics: TallySystems, South Africa, and The Bushmen (southern Africa).
Campbell, P. J. The geometry of decoration on prehistoric Pueblo pottery from Starkweather Ruin. Symmetry 2: unifying human understanding, Part 2. Comput. Math. Appl. 17 (1989), no. 4-6, 731--749. (Reviewer: M. P. Closs.) SC: 01A12 (92A90), MR: 90h:01003.
Starts by introducing the mathematical principles behind classifications of symmetry groups for strip or frieze patterns and the plane patterns, and briefly discusses some other symmetry groups. Next, reviews the literature of the papers that have used symmetry patterns to classify and analyze designs. All an excellent introduction. The remainder of the article applies these methods to the later Pueblo pottery at Starkweather Ruin (Tularosa black-on-white and Reserve black-on-white). Ends with a discussion of to what extent the work of these and similar potters was mathematical. Closes with a quotation by Schattschneider on the work of "amateurs": "The mind and spirit are the forte of all such amateurs---the intense spirit of inquiry and the keen perception of all they encounter. No formal education provides these gifts. Mere lack of a mathematical degree separates these 'amateurs' from the 'professional'. Yet their dauntless curiosity and ingenious methods make them true mathematicians." Closely related topics: Frieze Patterns, Bichromatic Strip Patterns, Plane Patterns, Pottery, and The Pueblo Indians.
Crowe, D. W. and Washburn, D. K. Groups and geometry in the ceramic art of San Ildefonso. Proceedings of the conference on groups and geometry, Part A (Madison, Wis., 1985). Algebras Groups Geom. 2 (1985), no. 3, 263--277. (Reviewer: H. S. M. Coxeter.) SC: 05B45 (00A05 01A12 20F32 52A45), MR: 87k:05055.
Discusses the types of frieze patterns and bichromatic strip patterns occurring in the pottery of the pueblo of San Ildefonso in New Mexico. The people of San Ildefonso are Tewa speaking and are thought to be of Anasazi descent. However, it should be noted that the pottery has apparently been influenced by the Spanish and by attempts to make it more readily salable. All 7 of the strip patterns and 14 of the 17 possible bichromatic strip patterns are exhibited. (The authors supply the missing 3 bichromatic strip patterns in a similar style. The authors supplement their discussion with an explanation of the appealing Coxeter notation for classifying the bichromatic patterns (the standard classification system is cumbersome) and give a table of the correspondences between various systems. A historical aside briefly discusses the study of plane patterns in the context of the Alhambra, where there is still some disagreement on which patterns are represented. Closely related topics: The Pueblo of San Ildefonso, Frieze Patterns, Bichromatic Strip Patterns, Plane Patterns, Pottery, The Islamic World, and Spain in the Middle Ages.
Crowe, Donald W. The geometry of African art. III. The smoking pipes of Begho. The geometric vein, pp. 177--189, Springer, New York-Berlin, 1981. (Reviewer: M. P. Closs.) SC: 01A10 (51M20), MR: 84b:01004.
Introduces the strip and plane patterns. Gives a useful flowchart for recognizing them (and some examples). Then classifies the patterns appearing in smoking pipes from the Krama quarter of Begho, in Ghana. The most common strip pattern is the one usually referred to as pmm2 (number 7 in the author's own system). The most common plane patterns are pmm and p4m. As the author notes, both of these can be easily created as rows of pmm2 strips. Representatives of all 7 strip patterns were found, but only 7 of the 17 possible plane patterns occurred. The author also considered questions on the relative preponderance of the various strip types by four different levels in the dig; no noticeable differences were found. Closely related topics: Ghana, Frieze Patterns, and Plane Patterns.
Deshpande, M. N. Archaeological sources for the reconstruction of the history of sciences of India. Indian J. History Sci. 6 (1971), 1--22. (Reviewer: A. I. Volodarskii.) SC: 01A25 (01A10), MR: 58 #15813.
A broad review of the archaeology of ancient India, focusing on the sciences. Perhaps a third of the article is devoted to a discussion of the Harappan civilization, and particularly Harappa and Mohenjo-Daro. Little is directly known about Harappan mathematics, but there are strong suggestions that there would have been some significant knowledge of surveying and possibly astronomy. The author also discusses the Harappan system of weights and measures. A good area for future research, particularly if some progress is made in reading the Harappan script. Closely related topics: The Harappan Civilization, Surveying, Astronomy, The Balance and the Measurement of Weight, and The Measurement of Distance.
Dibble, William E. A possible Pythagorean triangle at Stonehenge. J. Hist. Astronom. 7 (1976), no. 2, 141--142. (Reviewer: C. R. Fletcher.) SC: 01A10, MR: 58 #20990a.
Dibble notes that one triangle at Stonehenge is rather close to a 5,12,13 Pythagorean right triangle. The conclusion is bound to be controversial, and Dibble is cautious about making definite claims. Closely related topics: The Stone Builders and Pythagorean Triangles and Triples.
Evans, Brian. Number and form and content: a composer's path of inquiry. The Visual Mind, 113--120, Leonardo Book Series, MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass., 1993.
The author shows how the golden ratio occurs in music and art. His examples include Mozart's Symphony in G Minor, Grant Wood's American Gothic, Piet Mondrian's Composition with Blue, and some of his own musical and visual compositions. More controversial examples include the Great Pyramid in Egypt and Stonehenge, where the author shows how approximate values of both pi and the golden ratio can be found. The author mentions Luca Pacioli's statements on the golden ratio in De Divina Proportione and discusses other aspects of the philosophy of number and art as well. Closely related topics: Proportion and the Golden Ratio, Music, Art, Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart (1756-1791), Luca Pacioli, The Egyptian Pyramids, and The Stone Builders.
Knorr, W. R. The geometer and the archaeoastronomers: on the prehistoric origins of mathematics. Review of: Geometry and algebra in ancient civilizations [Springer, Berlin, 1983; MR: 85b:01001] by B. L. van der Waerden. British J. Hist. Sci. 18 (1985), no. 59, part 2, 197--212. SC: 01A10, MR: 87k:01003.
The reviewer discusses van der Waerden's book Geometry and Algebra in Ancient Civilizations. Although the reviewer clearly admires van der Waerden for his work in algebra and in the history of mathematics in general, he is highly critical of the conclusions reached in van der Waerden's book. A basic theme of the book is that there is a pre-Babylonian ancestor to mathematics in Babylonia, ancient Egypt, Greece, China and India; thus the book can therefore be thought of in part as a further development of Abraham Seidenberg's theories on the ritual origins of ancient mathematics. The reviewer takes issue with several facts cited in the book, and in addition with three assumptions that he sees van der Waerden using explicitly or implicitly in the book: "(1) independent discovery is so rare that it may effectively be discounted as a working hypothesis for relating technical traditions; (2) derivative traditions are inferior to their source traditions; (3) borrowing from one tradition to another is not selective, but entails the adoption of whole bodies of technique." (The phrase "inferior to" in (2) could just as well be replaced by "degraded in".) The reviewer suggests in addition that van der Waerden has not been sufficiently critical in accepting claims by Alexander Thom and others about advanced mathematics in megalithic monuments, and sees these claims as forming "the veritable linchpin of van der Waerden's thesis". The author briefly discusses some of Thom's work in megalithic mathematics, and concludes that he finds no real evidence of the Pythagorean theorem, the ellipse, or a standard unit of distance in neolithic times. The review concludes with the statement "I fear even more the regrettable impact on credulous nonspecialists who may not know to distinguish between the general enterprise of scientific research and the reckless notions of some scientists." Closely related topics: Sumerians and Babylonians, Ancient Egypt, Greece, China, India, The Stone Builders, Alexander Thom, and Pythagorean Triangles and Triples.
Petruso, Karl M. Additive progression in prehistoric mathematics: a conjecture. Historia Math. 12 (1985), no. 2, 101--106. (Reviewer: Garry J. Tee.) SC: 01A10 (01A15), MR: 86m:01005.
A collection of stone balance weights was recovered from a Late Bronze Age ship (c. 1200 BC) that sank off the coast of southern Turkey (near Cape Gelidonya, modern Finike). Some of these weights are sphendonoid in shape ("approximately the shape of an olive pit"), and appear to be multiples 1, 3, 5, 7, 12, 31, 50, and 54 of a hypothetical unit weight of 9.3 grams (the error is within about 2 percent). There are five weights of 7, and one weight of each of the others. Initially, these balance weights defied analysis, but the author (Petruso) realized that they nearly form a Fibonacci series; he posits the existence of missing weight of 2 and 19. Two problems with this interpretation are the fact that a weight of 7 occurs instead of a weight of 8, and the fact that the weight of 54 does not fit into his system. He suggests that the weight of 8 is a "purposeful and quite utilitarian shift in the basic Fibonacci series .... [to] allow the generation of a 50-unit (rather than 55-unit) mass further along the series." He also notes that the units of 19+31+50 would conveniently add up to 100. As for the 54 unit weight, "it might well have had a specific, idiosyncratic (industrial) purpose which is now lost to us." The author notes that one particular advantage of the Fibonacci-like system is that the accuracy of the individual weights could be quickly checked: for example, one can weigh the 12 against the 5 and the 7. Altogether a fascinating theory, readily readable. Closely related topics: The Balance and the Measurement of Weight, Leonardo of Pisa (Fibonacci), and The Late Bronze Age.
Riese, Tara A. and Chen, Yong Zhuo. Crop circles and Euclidean geometry. Internat. J. Math. Ed. Sci. Tech. 25 (1994), no. 3, 343--346. (Reviewer: E. J. F. Primrose.) SC: 51M04 (01A99), MR: 95b:51018.
This article can be viewed as a supplement to an article by I. Peterson (Science News 141 (1992), no. 5, 76--77) in which the author discusses "Gerald S. Hawkins, a retired astronomer, who was fascinated by the intriguing configuration of crop circles near Stonehenge in southern England. After a systematic study of the crop formations, he discovered five geometric theorems which cannot be found in any Euclidean geometry textbooks and references. Four of them were stated in that article. The fifth, he left to the reader to figure out." These theorems turn out to be quite elementary, but might still be of some interest to an introductory geometry class; when Riese and Yong-Zhou Chen used Peterson's article in their geometry class they had "an exciting discussion on Hawkins's theorems", and the class was able to develop its own version of the fifth theorem. The class's theorem is given in the paper, together with three other simple theorems describing the relationships between circles and n-gons. Closely related topics: The Stone Builders, The Circle, and Education.
Toth, Nicholas. The prehistoric roots of a human concept of symmetry. Symmetry in a kaleidoscope, 3. Symmetry Cult. Sci. 1 (1990), no. 3, 257--281. (Reviewer: J. S. Joel.) SC: 01A10 (00A99), MR: 93g:01005.
The author discusses how concepts of symmetry occur in Paleolithic artifacts such as stone tools and "Venus" figurines, and also in the roughly circular areas such as those used in a hut or even perhaps at Olduvai site DK 1 (some million years ago). The author has also noted some asymmetries in the making of flaked stone tools. "This slight but statistically significant patterning of asymmetry and possible preferential right-handedness between 1.9 and 1.5 million years ago may indicate a more profound specialization (lateralization) of the left and right hemispheres of the hominid brain by the early stone age." Closely related topics: The Paleolithic Era, Symmetry, and Biology.