To refine search, see subtopics Beethoven and Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart (1756-1791). Laterally related topics: Religion, Time and Space, Mathematics in Recreation, Art, Language and Literature, Measurement, Arithmetic, Mathematics and Mysticism, Geometry, Discrete Mathematics, Optimization, Philosophy, Calculus, Statistics, Social Science, Logic, Computation, Probability, Applied Mathematics (General), Education, Algebra, Number Theory, Optics, Archaeology, Medicine, Creativity, Business, Fractals, and Science.
The Mathematics and the Liberal Arts pages are intended to be a resource for student research projects and for teachers interested in using the history of mathematics in their courses. Many pages focus on ethnomathematics and in the connections between mathematics and other disciplines. The notes in these pages are intended as much to evoke ideas as to indicate what the books and articles are about. They are not intended as reviews. However, some items have been reviewed in Mathematical Reviews, published by The American Mathematical Society. When the mathematical review (MR) number and reviewer are known to the author of these pages, they are given as part of the bibliographic citation. Subscribing institutions can access the more recent MR reviews online through MathSciNet.
Chandrasekhar, S. Shakespeare, Newton and Beethoven or patterns of creativity. Current Sci. 70 (1996), no. 9, 810--822. SC: 01A99, MR: 1 387 202.
Discusses the creative lives of Shakespeare, Newton, and Beethoven. The example of Newton contrasts with the other two, particularly in how old they were when they did their most creative work. While the best work of poets is often later in life, G. H. Hardy tells us that the best work of mathematicians is generally when they are young. Chandrasekhar gives the additional examples of the mathematicians or scientists James Clerk Maxwell, George Gabriel Stokes, and Albert Einstein. Lord Rayleigh's example is different, and gives us a possible explanation of the differences we've seen. In the words of J. J. Thomson, "There are some great men of science whose charm consists in having said the first word on a subject, in having introduced some new idea which has proved fruitful; there are others whose charm consists perhaps in having said the last word on the subject, and who have reduced the subject to logical consistency and clearness. I think by temperament Lord Rayleigh belonged to the second group." Chandrasekhar then discusses the importance of beauty to mathematics and science, and concludes with statements of scientists and poets on one or the other of the two disciplines (some comments are more favorable than others). Closely related topics: Creativity, Shakespeare, Isaac Newton (1642-1727), and Beethoven.Modify notes on this entry Modify bibliography entry Make comment on this entry
Evans, Brian. Number and form and content: a composer's path of inquiry. The Visual Mind, 113--120, Leonardo Book Series, MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass., 1993.
The author shows how the golden ratio occurs in music and art. His examples include Mozart's Symphony in G Minor, Grant Wood's American Gothic, Piet Mondrian's Composition with Blue, and some of his own musical and visual compositions. More controversial examples include the Great Pyramid in Egypt and Stonehenge, where the author shows how approximate values of both pi and the golden ratio can be found. The author mentions Luca Pacioli's statements on the golden ratio in De Divina Proportione and discusses other aspects of the philosophy of number and art as well. Closely related topics: Proportion and the Golden Ratio, Art, Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart (1756-1791), Luca Pacioli, The Egyptian Pyramids, and The Stone Builders.Modify notes on this entry Modify bibliography entry Make comment on this entry
Grattan-Guinness, I. Mozart 18, Beethoven 32: hidden shadows of integers in classical music. History of mathematics, 29--47, Academic Press, San Diego, CA, 1996. SC: 01A99 (00A69), MR: 97a:01075.
Discusses number symbolism in the works of Mozart and Beethoven. With Mozart, discusses in particular Die Zauberflöte and the last three symphonies (and particularly the Symphony in g of 1788). There is also some evidence that Mozart used gematria. Literary sources also attest to Mozart's interest in numerology. With Beethoven, focuses primarily on Piano Sonata op. 111 (no. 32), the Diabelli Variations, and the Missa Solemnis. The choice of opus numbers themselves appear to show an interest in numerology. The author suggests that some knowledge of the history and conventions of numerology would be useful before reading this article. The author's own article in the Companion Encyclopedia of the History and Philosophy of the Mathematical Sciences may be useful in this regard. The author also suggests some avenues for future research. Closely related topics: Numerology, Gematria, Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart (1756-1791), and Beethoven.Modify notes on this entry Modify bibliography entry Make comment on this entry
Grattan-Guinness, I. Some numerological features of Beethoven's output. Ann. of Sci. 51 (1994), no. 2, 103--135. SC: 01A99 (00A69), MR: 1 278 119.
The author discusses possible occurrences of number symbolism in Beethoven's compositions. A large number of examples are used to buttress his arguments, and some prior familiarity with Beethoven's work might be useful. In some cases, numbers occur as the number of measures or notes of a them or motif, and in other cases in Beethoven's choice of opus numbers. (In contrast with the common practice of the time, Beethoven chose his opus numbers himself, and the numbers chosen could at times be seriously at variance with the order of composition.) The author's conclusions have been controversial, partly because Beethoven has often been regarded as being quite poor at arithmetic. The author discusses this objection and aspects of methodology in some detail. Closely related topics: Numerology and Beethoven.Modify notes on this entry Modify bibliography entry Make comment on this entry
Henle, Jim. Classical mathematics. Baroque mathematics. Romantic mathematics? Mathematics jazz! Also atonal, New Age, minimalist, and punk mathematics. Amer. Math. Monthly 103 (1996), no. 1, 18--29. SC: 01A99 (00A30 00A69), MR: 1 369 148.
Music is often broken into Renaissance, Baroque, Classical, and Romantic periods. This classification is not used so consistently in art and literature, and is rarely applied to mathematics, but the author finds reasonable ways to define these eras for the other disciplines as well. He finds that the periods correspond closely in art and literature, and that they correspond closely in music and mathematics, but that the periods in the latter lag significantly behind the periods in the former. This may suggest some linking between the two fields, the exact nature of which still remains to be determined. The author makes a few good-natured guesses about relationships between mathematics and other types of music as well. Atonalism is associated with formalism, jazz with topology, and, in essence, new age with dynamical systems. A very enjoyable article, and could be a good reading assignment for students in either a History of Mathematics or a Philosophy of Mathematics course. Closely related topics: Art History, Literature, and Philosophy.Modify notes on this entry Modify bibliography entry Make comment on this entry
Nagy, Dénes. Symmet-origami (symmetry and origami) in art, science, and technology. Symmetry Cult. Sci. 5 (1994), no. 1, 3--12. SC: 00A69 (01A99), MR: 1 309 239.
Discusses the history and philosophy of origami and then (in a little more depth) discusses some of its applications. The author discusses applications in math and science education, and also in art, design, and technology. A particularly interesting application of paper-folding and the theory of polyhedra is in music education, where one researcher devised "a 'tower' of five octahedra, to illustrate some basic concepts in musicology. His inspiration was from a work by Möbius written in 1861. Ganter's compound polyhedron illustrates geometrically the following concepts and their connections: the vertices correspond to the notes of the chromatic scale, the edges corresponds to the thirds and fifths, and the triangular faces correspond to the triads." He mentions that M. C. Escher was interesting in construction paper models (though it is not really clear how deep that interest lay). It is interesting that the well-known book by T. Sundara Row entitled Geometric Exercises in Paper Folding seems to be independent from the Japanese traditions. Closely related topics: Origami, Symmetry, Japan, Education, M. C. Escher, and August Ferdinand Möbius (1790-1868).Modify notes on this entry Modify bibliography entry Make comment on this entry
Nagy, Dénes. The 2,500-year old term symmetry in science and art and its "missing link" between the antiquity and the modern age. Symmetry: natural and artificial, 1 (Washington, DC, 1995). Symmetry Cult. Sci. 6 (1995), no. 1, 18--28. SC: 01A99, MR: 1 371 622.
Documents the evolution of the word symmetry from its beginnings in ancient Greece. As the author explains, the word originally had a somewhat different meaning: symmetry = syn together + metron measure, suggesting the notion of commensurability. The word was adopted into Latin but was apparently rare in the middle ages. It's reappearance can probably be credited to the importance to the Renaissance of the De architectura libri decem of Vitruvius (1st century BC). The author discusses the Hebrew, Indian, and Chinese words for symmetry as well. At the end of the article the author enumerates some modern generalizations and uses of symmetry. For example, the author mentions "Noether's theorems connecting symmetry transformations (invariances) and conservation laws", Gell-Mann and Ne'eman's classification of elementary particles, and "Graeser's reconstruction of Bach's Kunst der Fuge". Closely related topics: Symmetry, Language and Literature, Greece, Vitruvius, and Physics.Modify notes on this entry Modify bibliography entry Make comment on this entry
Schroeder, Manfred R. Number theory and the real world. Math. Intelligencer 7 (1985), no. 4, 18--26. (Reviewer: M. Mendès France.) SC: 11-02 (00A69 01A99), MR: 87b:11001.
We learn in this interesting article that number theory has applications to, or at least connections, with the real world. The author begins with a discussion of the division of the scale into twelve equal semitones, and how this appears natural from the continued fraction representation of log23. Next, he discusses the acoustics of concert halls, and how ceilings designed with a knowledge of quadratic residues can better convert sound waves traveling longitudinally into lateral waves, and thereby produce a more accurate stereophonic effect. Another suggestion of the author on wave diffraction involves primitive roots. (If the reader wants to really understand this part of the article, some knowledge of physics will be necessary.) The author then discusses of applications of finite fields to error correcting codes and even a verification of Einstein's General Theory of Relativity (the slowing of electromagnetic radiation in a gravitational field, observed with radar echos of the planets Venus and Mercury). The applications of modular arithmetic to cryptography and fast methods of multiplication are more widely known, but will come as a pleasant surprise to the uninitiated. Many other applications are also briefly mentioned. The author has written a book Number Theory in Science and Communication: With Applications in Cryptography, Physics, Biology, Digital Information and Computing (Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1984) that discusses these and other applications in more detail. Closely related topics: Number Theory, Acoustics, Astronomy, Information Theory, and Arithmetic.Modify notes on this entry Modify bibliography entry Make comment on this entry
Scriba, Christoph J. Mathematics and music. (Danish) Normat 38 (1990), no. 1, 3--17, 52. SC: 01A99 (00A69), MR: 91i:01154.
The author discusses the relationship between mathematics and music from Pythagorean through modern times. His story begins in in Pythagorean times, and as he explains, the notes of the musical scale were then determined by the ratio of a perfect fifth, i.e. 3:2. Twelve intervals of a fifth are roughly equal to seven octaves, but are in reality slightly more than seven octaves, the discrepancy being the "Pythagorean comma" of 312:219, or roughly 74:73. Whole steps in the scale were in the ratio 9:8, and half steps were in the ratio 256:243. Thus two half steps were slightly less than one whole step. In fact, Philolaus noted that one whole note is equal to two half notes plus a Pythagorean comma. Archytas showed that intervals like the octave 2:1, fifth 3:2, fourth 4:3, and whole tone 9:8, or any other interval in the ratio (n+1):n cannot in fact be divided with rational numbers into two equal intervals. However, he noted that the product of the arithmetic mean and the harmonic mean is equal to the square of the geometric mean, so this gave a way of dividing the fifth of 3:2 into the product of 5:4 and 6:5. 5:4 can be thought of as a major third, and 6:5 can be though of as a minor third. So the ratio 3:2 is divided as 6:5:4. Similarly, the fourth of 4:3 can be divided into the product of 7:6 and 8:7, so the ratio 4:3 is divided as 8:7:6. The interval 7:6 can be though of as a shrunken minor third and 8:7 can be though of as an enlarged whole tone. Scriba suggests that the germs of the idea of making this division lie with the Babylonians.In the Renaissance, the musical scale was modified to take some of these ideas into account through the work of theoreticians like Ludovico Fogliano and Giusseppe Zarlino. For example, the ratio for the notes E:C and A:F were changed from the Pythagorean 81:64 (two whole tones) to the ratio 5:4. B moved to stay a whole tone of 9:8 above A. Thus the half tones F:E and c:B were now in the ratio 16:15 rather than the Pythagorean 256:243. The whole tones C:D, F:G, and A:B remained in the ratio 9:8, but the whole tones D:E and G:A were now in the ratio 10:9. (It was roughly in the same time interval that intervals of a third began to be considered consonant.) Sharps and flats did not coincide: C sharp and D flat were for example different notes. However, it wasn't long before there were efforts to make a scale of 12 uniform steps. The first to attempt to do so was Galileo Galilei's father, Vincenso Galilei. He tried to make each step of size 18:17, though that of course led to problems. It was Simon Stevin who first had the idea of making uniform steps of size 21/12.
Later on, some mathematicians even began to question the division of the scale into 12 tones, with the idea that a division into a different number of notes might lead to a more perfect representation of the intervals. For example Christiaan Huygens defined a 31-tone system of temperament in his Lettre touchant le cycle harmonique. One source even suggests that this has "led indirectly to a tradition of 31-tone music in the Netherlands in this century". Leonhard Euler's efforts involved an attempt to reconcile the ideal "octave" 2:1 with the ideal "fifth" 3:2. He analyzed the problem by using a continued fraction representation of the ratio log 2:log 3/2. The convergent 12/7 corresponds to the popular division of 7 octaves into a circle of 12 fifths. Other convergents include 17/12, 29/17, 41/24, and 53/31. In the last case, for example, 31 octaves would be divided into 53 fifths. These didn't answer the question of what kind of equally tempered scale best reconciles the intervals of an octave, fifth, and third (2:1, 3:2, and 5:4) simultaneously. This may or may not influence the course of music, but Scriba shows how an algorithm by the Norwegian mathematician Viggo Brun (1885-1978) gives an answer. If the best answers are written in terms of the number of steps in the three intervals, the best approximations are (2,1,1), (3,2,1), (5,3,2), (7,4,2), (12,7,4), (19,11,6), (31,18,10), (34,20,11), (53,31,17), (87,51,28), .... The triple (12,7,4) is the common case with 12 semitones in an octave, 7 in a "major fifth", and 4 in a "major third". As Scriba explains, the case of the 31 tone scale has been especially important historically. In fact, Scriba tells us that it was back in the middle of the 1600s that Nicolas Vicentino described a "archicembalo" with six manuals with the octave divided into 31 parts; as mentioned above, Huygens clarified this. Moreover, Scriba tells us that Zarlino and Salinas shortly thereafter discussed the division of the octave into 19 equal parts. There is apparently an organ built according to the principles of the Dutch physicist D. Fokker (1887-1972) that also divides the octave into 31 parts (it is now in the Teylers Museum in Haarlem). Along a different line, Euler tried to design a mathematical system to quantify the dissonance of chords, but it apparently did not work very well.
The next part of the article discusses some of the work of Wolfgang Graesers (1906-1928), who tried to do a mathematical study of Bach's Art of the Fugue (this was published under the name Bachs "Kunst der Fuge" (German) in the Bach-Jahrbuch 1924, pages 1-104). Here, group theoretic notions reflect the kinds of transformations, such as inversion, that can be used in a fugue. A background in music theory may be useful in understanding Graesers's work.